Is Choice the Problem?

Civilization as we know it depends on a widespread belief in the notion of free will. Benjamin Libet and many other scientists, however, have repeatedly demonstrated otherwise. If there is no free will then the problem is not choice. This notion would solve a lot of problems and may create new ones.

The most beautiful scientific theories are also the most parsimonious. Therefore, I will refer to a dialogue between C. A. Swan and Tony Wendice in one of my favorite Hitchcock movies. How does Wendice know Swan will agree? “For the same reason that a donkey with a stick behind and a carrot in front always goes forwards and not backwards.”